Florida SB-4D: The Perfect Storm for New Unintended Consequences?

Potential Terminations of Condo and Co-ops and the Feeding Frenzy by Developers Waiting in the Wings  

Florida’s Senate Bill 4-D (SB-4D) was passed in response to the tragic Champlain Towers collapse in 2021. This disaster, which claimed the lives of 98 people, sent shockwaves through Florida’s hi-rise real estate market and raised urgent questions about building safety, inspections, and accountability. 

On the surface, the bill seemed to be the logical response to ensure that such a tragedy would never happen again. However, the potential nightmare facing property owners in high rise condos and co-ops far exceeds the initial damages from three years ago.   

The harsh reality is that SB-4D is creating a financial nightmare for countless condo and co-op owners by imposing strict reserve requirements and if necessary massive assessments.  Many property owners will not be able to afford these requirements and will be squeezed out, opening the door for wealthy developers to swoop in and buy up these properties at rock-bottom prices. We are looking at a possible major collapse of the Florida condominium and co-op market on coastal lands in Florida.    

Based on some of our conversations with real estate professionals and Florida Association Attorneys, developers are already “chumming” the waters for Associations who cannot bear the financial burden of SB-4D and will be filing for “termination of their corporations in preparation to sell off their assets.  This will be a “Win” for the Developers and speculators and a “Lose” for the property owners who will be selling off what would be considered “distressed” property.  It will also impact the tax base for the State until the entire “Association Sham” cycle is reconstructed all over again at a higher price tag. Upending the lives of countless people.    

SB-4D: What Does the Law Say? 

SB-4D was created in response to concerns about aging condominium buildings and the need for increased oversight to prevent further structural failures. At its core, the bill mandates for buildings three stories and higher: 

1. Mandatory Inspections: Condominium buildings that are 30 years old (or 25 years old if they are near the coast) must undergo detailed structural inspections every ten years. The cost of these inspections and any required repairs falls squarely on the shoulders of the condo owners. 

1. Strict Reserve Requirements: Condominiums must now keep significantly higher reserves on hand for structural repairs. This is meant to ensure that critical maintenance and repairs are funded before they become catastrophic issues. 

1. Special Assessments: In cases where reserve funds are insufficient to cover necessary repairs, condo associations are allowed to issue hefty special assessments— bills that condo owners are required to pay to cover the costs. 

While these provisions are ostensibly designed to protect residents and ensure the long-term stability of Florida’s aging condominium stock, the reality is that many condo owners are now facing crippling financial assessments. In some cases, these assessments run into tens or even hundreds of thousands of dollars per unit, leaving many owners unable to pay. 

Has SB-4D created the perfect storm for the next wave of unintended consequences?  

Insurance companies are being shielded from extensive liability:  

Insurance premiums have skyrocketed, and the insurance industry has pushed for even more stringent building requirements and reserve funds to limit their own liability.  Squeezing property owners from all sides. 

Developers looking at a potential real estate feeding frenzy:  

Florida’s prime coastal real estate has been long coveted by developers but, in many cases, the land has been tied up in aging buildings that were difficult to redevelop. With SB-4D, which will most likely force owners to sell due to unsustainable costs, developers will have ample opportunities to swoop in and buy up entire buildings for pennies on the dollar.   

SB-4D Will Definitely Push Property Owners Out 

Hi-rise Condo and Co-Op owners are the ultimate victims of SB-4D, as the financial pressures it imposes make it nearly impossible for many to remain in their homes.  

Once a building fails its inspection or is found to need significant repairs, associations are required to address the issues immediately.  If reserve funds aren’t sufficient, property owners will be hit with massive special assessments to cover the costs. These assessments can range from tens of thousands to hundreds of thousands of dollars, depending on the scope of the repairs. 

Many of these owners, especially retirees or those on fixed incomes, will not be able to afford to pay these assessments. Faced with no other choice, they most likely will be forced to sell their units—often at a steep discount—just to avoid foreclosure by their associations for unpaid assessments. 

What Can These Property Owners Do Now?  Is it too little too late?  

Maybe, maybe not!   

We Recommend that you Push Back! 

Push back against your elected officials who voted for this fiasco in the first place. Make them come to the table to renegotiate the terms and conditions with you, the property owners.  

Not the special interests who write the laws or hire lobbyists to get the legislation they want, not the insurance cartel, not the association lawyers, not the property management companies, not with your out of touch board of directors, but with you the property owners.  

Join the US Coalition for Association Reform: A membership organization that represents the rights of property owners in association communities first and foremost.  We are dedicated to changing how associations are governed to better safeguard and advance the rights of individual property owners. Through advocacy, legal action, and pushing for changes in government and legislative reform, we can restore property rights and bring fairness, honesty, and accountability back to communities like yours. 

In Conclusion: 

SB-4D was supposed to protect Floridians from another tragedy like the Champlain Towers collapse. Instead, it will collapse many other buildings in its wake, driving condo and co-op owners out of their homes and into financial ruin.  The longer it remains unchallenged, the more damage it will create. Don’t let yourself become a victim of this fiasco, get informed, join the fight at www.uscfar.com, and stand up for your rights before it’s too late.  

Get The Feeding Frenzy Limited Edition Tee Shirt at the USCFAR Shop Now >>